Why financial advisor diversity makes good business sense

The financial services industry is grounded in the belief that everyone deserves access to professional financial advice. Increasing financial advisor diversity is crucial for achieving this vision. In the hope of sparking action, I’ve outlined three ways a more diverse and inclusive workplace can benefit your practice and steps for achieving it.

Current state of financial advisor diversity

From our day-to-day interactions as financial services professionals, we have a general sense of the lack of diversity and inclusion in the industry. But some sobering statistics from Cerulli Associates really drive this point home—only 12.3% of financial advisors identify as a person of a different race or ethnicity and 18.1% are women (up 2.4% from 2015).1 It’s time for meaningful change in our industry. Becoming more diverse and inclusive will help us all better fulfill our mission to positively affect the financial lives of others.

Advisor gender, race, and ethnicity in 2019

Bar chart shows that only 12.3% of financial advisors are a person of a different race or ethnicity and 18.1% are women

Source: “U.S. Advisor Metrics 2020: Dimensions of Diversity and Inclusion,” The Cerulli Report, Cerulli Associates, 2020. 

Benefits of a diverse practice 

What can you do to be part of this change? Consider making diversity part of your strategic plan, if you haven’t already. A diverse and inclusive workplace can help your practice thrive because it provides:

  • Fresh perspectives—You want a team that brings innovative ideas and solutions to the table and isn’t afraid to challenge the status quo. Diverse backgrounds and experiences mean diverse viewpoints, which can lead to constructive conversations about revenue opportunities, client service, and operations.
  • New business prospects—People generally prefer to receive advice from financial advisors to whom they can relate. Fifty-eight percent of female advisors say that at least 50% of their primary client contacts are women, compared with only one-third of male advisors.1 A more diverse practice can open doors to previously untapped markets, expanding your reach.
  • A succession plan—The financial services industry is aging, with 35% of advisors planning to retire in the next 10 years, and there aren’t enough new advisors to replace them.1 This means you’ll need to get creative with your recruitment, using channels you may not have previously considered. (We’ll talk more about recruitment in the next section.) Having a broader talent pipeline can minimize the disruption when advisors in your firm retire, helping ensure a smooth transition for clients.

Building diversity and inclusion in the workplace 

Adding diversity to your strategic plan means analyzing all aspects of your practice to identify opportunities to become more diverse and inclusive.

Rethink your recruitment process

Do you rely on referrals from family members, colleagues, or your professional networks? While there’s nothing inherently wrong with this approach, it limits your talent pool, and you’re likely getting many candidates who reflect your firm’s current demographics. Expand your outreach to help connect with non-Caucasian advisors—17% found their first advisory job through college campus recruiting—as well as female advisors.1 Work with professional recruiters and recruiting websites, such as workplacediversity.com, hispanicdiversity.com, and employdiversity.com, to attract a broader group of candidates.* Partner with local organizations that serve underrepresented communities to reach individuals who don’t have industry connections. Go where the candidates are.

We all know that having a written goal makes people feel more accountable and can help motivate us to act, so consider making a formal commitment to make your practice more diverse within a certain period. John Hancock and Manulife have set a goal that at least 25% of annual graduate hiring will be black, indigenous, and people of color by 2025.

Refresh advisor training, resources, and policies

Recruiting diverse talent isn’t enough. You have to retain them, and that can be challenging because the traditional business model—lack of stable compensation, pressure to meet revenue goals, and limited training—makes it hard for all new advisors to succeed. While the advisory business model won’t change overnight, we can take steps to increase the probability of success.

Establish a mentoring program that encourages diversity, with women guiding and championing other women, and advisors of color doing the same. Many successful people attribute their accomplishments to having a mentor who served as their advocate, teacher, and sounding board. Along that same line, institute a team approach, where junior advisors are paired with senior ones to help them learn the business and potentially take over when the senior members retire—an approach already commonly used, but with a lack of diversity. More than half of white advisors are part of a team, compared with 22% of black or African American advisors, 41% of Hispanic or Latino advisors, and 44% of Asian advisors.1

Team structure by advisor race and ethnicity, 2020

Bar chart shows more than 50% of white advisors are part of team compared with 22% of black or African American advisors, 41% of  Hispanic or Latino advisors, and 44% of Asian advisors

Source: “U.S. Advisor Metrics 2020: Dimensions of Diversity and Inclusion,” The Cerulli Report, Cerulli Associates, 2020.

Provide flexible schedules that support work/life balance. While gender roles have blurred, women are still the primary caregiver for children and adult family members. Of the roughly 53 million American caregivers, 61% are female.2 In addition, younger generations have different expectations for their careers. While they value hard work, they want time to pursue their passions outside the office and the freedom to work remotely. Adopting policies that address these needs can help foster loyalty and retain high-performing talent.

Create a culture of inclusivity, helping people put biases aside and celebrate differences. At John Hancock, we sponsor a variety of employee resource groups (ERGs), which are voluntary, employee-led networks united by a common identity, trait, or interest. These groups enable us to work together to address barriers to advancement and provide professional development opportunities. You may think your practice isn’t big enough to have ERGs, but there are ways to achieve the same objective on a smaller scale. The key is to create a feeling of community for all through constructive conversations in a safe, judgment-free environment.      

Reimagine your community involvement

One of the primary reasons women and people of color—and recent college grads—don’t pursue a career in financial services is because they’re not familiar with our industry.1 Community outreach can change that. Once again, it’s about meeting potential candidates where they are and deepening local ties. Look for opportunities for your advisory team to engage young adults through mentorship and financial education programs. Join organizations that support diversity, equity, and inclusion. For example, John Hancock has partnered with the MLK Scholars Program in Boston as a means of introducing underserved communities to careers in financial services.  

Financial advisor diversity—a win for your practice and those you serve

Our industry has reached the point where diversity and inclusion in the workplace aren’t just nice to haves but vital contributors to a thriving practice. Having diverse talent can bring in fresh perspectives, help you attract new clients, build a succession plan, and deepen your connection to your community. A diverse practice also means individuals can receive financial advice from an advisor they can relate to on a personal level. And in the end, isn’t that what it’s all about? 

 

1 “U.S. Advisor Metrics 2020: Dimensions of Diversity and Inclusion,” The Cerulli Report, Cerulli Associates, 2020. 2Caregiving in the U.S.,” AARP, May 2020.

*These websites are provided for informational purposes only and are not endorsed or sponsored by John Hancock. Their inclusion here shall not, in any manner, be construed as an endorsement of such websites or their products, services, or statements.

The content of this document is for general information only and is believed to be accurate and reliable as of the posting date, but may be subject to change. It is not intended to provide investment, tax, plan design, or legal advice (unless otherwise indicated). Please consult your own independent advisor as to any investment, tax, or legal statements made herein.

MGTS-P 44842-GE 8/21-44842                 MGR0818211758653

Gwendolyn McCoy

Gwendolyn McCoy, 

U.S. Head of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion

John Hancock

Read bio